Shower Tray vs Bathtub A Comprehensive Guide to Cost Efficiency and ROI in Bathroom Remodeling

Ivy Redmond
Jul 21
4 min read

Are you giving your bathroom a makeover? One of the biggest choices you’ll face is whether to install a shower tray or a bathtub. This decision impacts not just the look and feel of the bathroom, but also your budget and the potential return on investment (ROI) when it’s time to sell. As we explore both options here, you'll find insights that help you make the best choice for your remodel.

Understanding Shower Trays and Bathtubs

Before comparing costs, it’s essential to know the basics of each option.

A shower tray is a flat platform that forms the base of a shower enclosure. Its main job is to catch water and guide it toward the drainage system. In contrast, a bathtub is designed for soaking, providing a substantial water volume for relaxation.

Both fixtures offer different benefits to the overall look, usability, and value of your bathroom.

Cost Efficiency: Shower Tray vs Bathtub

Initial Costs

Initial costs are a key factor in your choice. Generally, shower trays are more affordable upfront than bathtubs.

Shower Tray: You can find standard shower trays priced between $200 to $600 based on size and materials. Installation is simpler, leading to lower labor costs.
Bathtub: Basic models start at $300, but prices can soar to over $5,000 for high-end versions with jets. Plus, installation can range from $1,000 to $2,000 if new plumbing fixtures are needed.

In terms of initial expenses, shower trays often provide a more economical route for homeowners.

Maintenance Costs

Looking beyond initial costs, maintenance is another important consideration.

Shower Tray: These fixtures typically require less upkeep. They are easier to clean, and because water does not pool like it does in bathtubs, there's a lower risk of mold and mildew.
Bathtub: Regular cleaning is crucial to prevent buildup of grime and soap scum. Bathtubs can scratch and stain over time, leading to additional costs.

In the long run, shower trays often save money on maintenance, making them a cost-effective choice.

Return on Investment (ROI)

ROI for Shower Trays

When you think about selling your home, shower trays can be a smart investment.

Popularity: Recent trends show that 66% of homebuyers, particularly younger ones, prefer walk-in showers. This makes shower trays an attractive feature.
Aesthetic Appeal: A well-designed shower can create an illusion of space, enhancing the overall look of the bathroom. A trendy, stylish shower can increase a home's value and attract potential buyers.

In urban areas, where space is limited, installing a shower tray can yield a solid return on investment.

ROI for Bathtubs

Bathtubs also offer unique value, especially for families.

Child-Friendly: For homes with young children, bathtubs are often non-negotiable. They provide an essential feature that appeals to family-oriented buyers.
Luxury Appeal: A high-quality bathtub can enhance a home’s luxury feel, particularly if it features unique designs, such as freestanding styles.

However, the trend is shifting, and many buyers now prioritize efficiency and lower maintenance.

Types of Bathtubs and Shower Trays

Bathtub Types

Choosing the right type of bathtub can significantly influence your decision:

Freestanding Bathtubs: These stand alone and can be placed anywhere, offering a luxurious, spa-like experience.
Built-in Bathtubs: Installed in a wall or alcove, these are often more practical for smaller spaces.
Corner Bathtubs: Specifically designed for corners, these save space while maintaining a stylish appearance.
Jacuzzi Bathtubs: Equipped with jets, these provide a relaxing soak but usually come at a higher price.

Shower Tray Types

Just like bathtubs, shower trays also come in various styles:

Standard Shower Trays: Commonly made of acrylic, these are budget-friendly options.
Ceramic Shower Trays: Durable and traditional-looking, these can be heavier and might complicate installation.
Stone or Slate Shower Trays: They offer a high-end, natural look but can be more expensive.
Low-Profile Shower Trays: Designed to sit closer to the ground, these make entry easier and provide a seamless aesthetic.

Your choice between these types depends on your style preferences, available bathroom space, and budget.

Overall Comparison: Shower Tray vs Bathtub

Space and Design Considerations

When planning your bathroom layout, space is crucial.

Shower Tray: These typically require less space, creating a more open and inviting feel, which is appealing to many buyers.
Bathtub: While they offer a luxurious feel, bathtubs take up more floor space, which can be a disadvantage in smaller bathrooms.

Accessibility and Safety

Accessibility is an essential factor, particularly for families or older adults.

Shower Tray: Many designs feature walk-in elements that enhance accessibility and minimize fall risks.
Bathtub: Traditional tubs can pose challenges for entry and exit, especially for individuals with mobility issues.

Eco-Friendliness

In a world increasingly concerned about sustainability, water usage matters.

Shower Tray: Showers typically use less water than baths. A quick shower often uses around 10 to 20 gallons, while a full bathtub can require 40 to 80 gallons.
Bathtub: Filling a bathtub can be wasteful, making it a less environmentally friendly choice.

Final Thoughts

Choosing between a shower tray and a bathtub comes down to practical considerations beyond just costs. Shower trays usually offer better cost efficiency and align with modern design preferences, while bathtubs remain valuable for family-friendly homes.

Ultimately, your decision should reflect your lifestyle needs and the tastes of potential buyers. In today's competitive real estate market, considering style, functionality, and cost can help you make the best choice for your bathroom remodel. No matter which option you choose, ensuring a high-quality installation and a cohesive design will play a crucial role in the success of your renovation.